Home

MixTape

News, notes and quotes from across the music world.

Previous Entry | Next Entry

independent minds

You don't really care for music, do you?

Posted by Tom Drew
  • Friday, 5 December 2008 at 02:42 pm
So this is Christmas. This time of year has two musical certainties: the first is that you're guaranteed to hear the same '80s and '90s seasonal songs, continuously, absolutely everywhere you go - of course, if you listen to Magic 105.4 this phenomenon isn't limited to the Christmas period; it's like Groundhog Day there.

The second certainty is that the Christmas number-one will be the most recent X Factor winner with a cover version of a song you didn't even like when it was originally released. The last single to top the yuletide charts that wasn't either a cover version or a song sung by the winner of a talent competition was the 2000 classic "Can We Fix It?" by Bob the Builder. I think that this fact alone proves that competitions such as the X Factor are stifling true creative genius.

This year will be slightly different, however, as the X Factor winner will be covering a creditable song, Jeff Buckley's "Hallelujah". Yes, I realise that Mr Buckley's version of "Hallelujah" was in itself a cover of Leonard Cohen's original, but I guarantee that the X Factor winner's version will essentially be a facsimile of the Buckley version, as every cover of that song has been post-1994; compare John Cale's 1991 cover with Allison Crowe's 2003 version, or Kate Voegele's or Imogen Heap's (yes, I watch too many American teen dramas).

As an added twist, Buckley's version is currently making an assault on the charts and, at No 34, it is nicely poised to get popular attention in time for Christmas following a massive increase in downloads after the BBC used the song to advertise its iPlayer service.

If you are inclined to buy your music, rather than illegally download it (remember, piracy is a crime, you wouldn't steal a car, would you?) I'd like to recommend that you download Buckley's version instead of the X Factor cover, after all, why have hamburger when you can have steak, why have Dairylea when you can have Roquefort, why have generic baked beans when you can have Heinz Baked Beanz? Can you tell this was written before I ate my lunch?

For more on "Hallelujah", read Elisa Bray's article in The Independent today, it's much more interesting than this. Also, for Buckley fans, his version of The Smith's "I Know It's Over" is just beautiful.

Comments

[info]lovelornloser wrote:
Tuesday, 9 December 2008 at 12:00 am (UTC)
I'm hoping for a rickrolling Christmas, myself. And if this facebook group is anything to go by, like everything else in life at present, we could be onto a winner - http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=19924740771

I can't really say I'm going to care for whatever is number 1 this year, and I've never been a fan of Jeff Buckley except for his "song to no one". Actially, I don't even listen to the radio, and haven't done for the past 10 years, so whilst everyone else is listening to whatever x factor regurgitates out, I'll be listening to Phil Spectors and the Beach Boys Christmas albums - which is probably what the rest of the radio airwaves are filled with.

-Russ
Xo

Edited at 2008-12-09 12:01 am (UTC)
Sounds like
[info]evereste wrote:
Thursday, 11 December 2008 at 02:25 am (UTC)
The melody is very close to Gene Loves Jezebel's SHAME, circa 1983... This song was also plagiarized by a band who had a h=uge it with "I could have died in your arms tonight", can't remember the name of the group but someone should tell GLJ.